This stems from a couple of binomial distribution projects I have been working on recently. It’s widely known that there are many different flavors of confidence intervals for the binomial distribution. The reason for this is that there is a coverage problem with these intervals (see Coverage Probability). A 95% confidence interval isn’t always (actually rarely) 95%. So I got curious what would happen if I generated random binomial data to find out what percent of the simulated data actually fell within the confidence interval. For simplicity I used . I wrote up some quick code that generates binomial data for varying sample sizes and runs a comparison for each of the nine confidence interval methods using the *binom.confint()* function.

library(binom)
set.seed(0)
nsims <- 10000
maxn <- 500
n <- seq(2,maxn, by=2)
my.method <- c("exact", "ac", "asymptotic", "wilson", "prop.test", "bayes", "logit", "cloglog", "probit")
my.method <- my.method[sort.list(my.method)]
coverage <- matrix(NA, nrow=length(n), ncol=length(my.method))
ci.lower <- ci.upper <- matrix(NA, ncol=length(my.method), nrow=length(n))
for(i in 1:length(n)){
m <- n[i]/2
y <- rbinom(nsims, n[i], m/n[i])
ll <- binom.confint(m,n[i], conf.level=.95, method=my.method)$lower
ul <- binom.confint(m,n[i], conf.level=.95, method=my.method)$upper
ci.lower[i,] <- ll
ci.upper[i,] <- ul
for(j in 1:length(my.method)){
sig <- length(y[y/n[i]<=ul[j] &amp;amp;amp;amp; y/n[i]>=ll[j]])
coverage[i,j] <- sig/nsims
}
}
plot(n,NULL, xlim=c(1,nrow(coverage)+1), ylim=c(.83,1),
col=1, pch=16, ylab="Percent", xlab="N",
main="95% Confidence Intervals for p=.5")
points(replicate(ncol(coverage),n),coverage, col=c(1:9),
pch=16, cex=.5)
abline(h=seq(.93,.97, by=.01), col="#EEEEEE")
abline(h=.95, col="#000000", lwd=2)
abline(v=seq(2,maxn, by=20), col="#EEEEEE")
legend("bottomright", my.method, col=c(1:9), pch=16, title="Interval Types", bg="#FFFFFF")
plot(n,NULL, xlim=c(1,100), ylim=c(0,1),
col=1, pch=16, ylab="Percent", xlab="N",
main="95% Confidence Interval for p=.5")
for(k in 1:ncol(coverage)){
lines(n, ci.lower[,k], col=k, lwd=1)
lines(n, ci.upper[,k], col=k, lwd=1)
}
legend("bottomright", my.method, col=c(1:9), ncol=2, lwd=1, title="Interval Types", bg="#FFFFFF")

/

### Like this:

Like Loading...

## Bob Muenchen

/ January 24, 2013Thanks for this great post! This prompted me to play around with the binom package. I knew the methods differed but I was surprised by how much! Time to read more journal articles.